Archive for July, 2008

Weekly News Roundup (27 July 2008)

Sunday, July 27th, 2008

Welcome to another WNR. My memory of the week was that it was pretty quiet, not many news stories at all, but when I went to check (the latest news forum), I actually found quite a few news items for the week. It’s funny how your memory can play tricks on you … like the other day when super-glued my mouse to my desk. Oh memory, when will you ever grow up!

CopyrightLet’s start with copyright news as per usual. One of the best ways that anti-piracy groups get people to notice them (and politicians to do what they say, apart from the large plain envelopes full of money that they give them) is to take statistics and then spin it their way. The BSA is just one such group that releases misleading stats to justify their actions, but you can read a detailed explanation of why these stats are misleading. Another way they do things is by holding back new technology and services and then blaming piracy for this, saying piracy adds too much risk to introducing these new services. And then they use this to sneak in new DRMs. The MPAA’s DVR-blocking initiative is one such example, and it is now backed by AT&T and DirecTV. The public pressure against this, I hope, will be enough to prevent it from happening.

MPAA's real definition

What MPAA really stands for?

And if sneaking in DRMs doesn’t work, then another way is to blame someone else for the problem and threaten to take action. That’s what the British Phonographic Industry did by blaming ISPs, and the UK ISPs relented and will now act as copyright cops for the BPI. And hypocrisy is another tool of the anti-piracy lobby, and it was revealed this week that the MPAA hired a hacker to spy on The Pirate Bay. Hacking is very illegal pretty much in every country in the world, and to hire someone to hack and spy on a foreign company is very naughty indeed, certainly much more naughtier than downloading an episode of Dexter that you happen to miss on TV.

And it’s not just the so called pirates that get the rough treatment. Often, the legitimate users are the worst affected, which then forces them to seek “illegal” alternatives. Take Yahoo’s DRM music service, which will be shut down and make all those legally purchased songs unplayable. Yahoo says they will compensate, but even if they give back all the money paid for these songs, people will still need to go out and find them again … how much time and effort will that be worth? The only fair compensation is to turn those music files DRM free, but they won’t do that of course. And if you think you’re rich and powerful, then you won’t become a victim of the copyright cops, think again. Senator McCain, US Republican Presidential nominee, might have just been caught by the copyright cops for copyright infringement in a campaign video lambasting Senator Obama. Of course, he’ll probably get away with it just like when Dubya was caught with an iPod full of pirated Beatles songs. 

High DefinitionIn HD news, not much news in the HD arena this week. But there was this very interesting article on how Sony beat Toshiba in the HD format war, and how close Sony came to oblivion just after Paramount ditched Blu-ray for HD DVD. I’ve always said that Sony won because they had it all to lose, and Toshiba didn’t have that kind of pressure to force them to go all the way.

DisplayPort - To replace HDMI soon?

DisplayPort - To replace HDMI soon?

Meanwhile, I get tired of reading the stories about “300% increase in Blu-ray sales”, because what exactly are they comparing the sales figures to? Last year this time when nobody was making and selling Blu-ray players? I’ve recently sold some Blu-ray movies on eBay as well, and I didn’t sell any last year, so my Blu-ray sales are up one billion percent! Take that, Wal-Mart! For the PC, if you want a HDMI equipped video card, now’s a good time because ATI is offering one for only $19 (after rebate). It still surprises me that HDMI hasn’t become standard on all video cards, although I suppose with DisplayPort on the way, one isn’t strictly necessary (and the added licensing cost of the DRM used can be avoided).

GamingAnd last but not least, in gaming, there is a brief peak at the new Xbox 360 Dashboard. Looks rather nice, I have to say. Microsoft is also encouraging users to build and sell their own games. Then came a series of what appears to be verbal tennis between Sony and Microsoft. I don’t know who started, but I’m sure they’re both grounded now.  Sony president Kaz Hirai first questioned the Xbox 360’s longevity, as compared to the PS3’s ten year plan. Microsoft responded by saying PS3 software sales will trail Xbox 360’s for this entire generation. Then Kaz Hirai said (might have been in the same interview as the above one) that he would rather die than have Xbox 360 exclusives on the PS3, not sure what this means to be honest. Although real people might die playing some PS3 exclusives, as it was revealed that Wipeout HD had to be re-designed because it failed an epilepsy test.

He started out playing Wii Sports you know

He started out playing Wii Sports you know

Meanwhile, laughing on the sidelines, Nintendo face some trouble of their own as they lost an appeal to a ruling that said the Wii controller infringed on patents, and they could be banned from selling controllers until this matter is resolved. Someone will give someone else a bag of money and the problem will go away ($21m, reportedly, which is what Nintendo makes every hour these days). While the matter might cause some of the lawyers involved high blood pressure, Nintendo wants to find out about your blood pressure. Pretty soon, there will be a Wii device that hook up to every part of your body. We’ll be like the Borg, except more stylish and family friendly. “Wii are the Borg. Resistance is fun for the whole family!”, that’s what we’ll say. And Americans are apparently better than Brits at Wii Sport. The fact that some scientists actually spent money on researching this is very funny to me.

Okay, that’s all the news we have for this week. Actually, that’s a lie because I left out a bunch of stuff I found boring or mundane, so it’s basically “that’s all the news that I found interesting/had time to post/wasn’t too drunk to pay atttention to this week”. Until next week, same Bat channel, same Bat time … (P.S surely The Dark Knight CANNOT be a better movie than The Godfather, Schindler’s List, Star Wars, Lord of the Rings, Citizen Kane … despite what you read on the IMDb)

More about CPUs

Saturday, July 26th, 2008

A couple of weeks ago I wrote something about CPUs and H.264 here, and this is just a post to follow it up. Since then, I’ve ran a poll on the type of CPU people uses, and the results are in. It’s not all that surprising, but it does give a good indication of the present AMD vs Intel war which Intel seems to be winning quite handsomely.

Let have a look at the results graph:

Breaking down the results into Intel vs AMD (vs Other), here’s what we have:

As you can see, Intel currently holds a good lead over AMD, where 60% of people polled had one of Intel’s CPUs, compared to only 37% that have AMDs. This is not really surprising, as AMD have only recently been able to properly respond to Intel’s Core 2 Duo/Quad range with the Phenom X3/X4s, largely thanks to AMD’s mistake of releasing the original Phenom with a memory addressing bug that caused huge performance problems.

What is also clear though is that while Intel has a well established brand name for it’s range of quad-core processors, AMD’s Phenom range hasn’t really taken off, and they are still reliant upon their Athlon range to fight against Intel’s Core 2 series. With the Phenom X3/X4s being priced very competitively against the Core 2 Quad, AMD’s Phenom series looks to have a bright future.

And AMD still does not have any processors that can compete with the Core 2 Extreme series … while it’s not a popular series, having the fastest CPU on the market definitely helps sell the other CPUs in the range.

Looking at the other end of the scale, at the budget processors, Intel again has many more options available than AMD, with Pentiums (both desktop and mobile), Celerons, Solos and the lower spec’d Core 2’s all competing against the Sempron and Turion.

So if AMD is to compete against Intel, then they need to focus more on the Phenom range, to pit it directly against the Core 2 Quad and some of the high end Core 2 Duos. They will also need to bring out a wider range of processors, to serve the budget through to the enthusiasts market, as it feels their current range is heavily focused around a very narrow price/performance range, with more emphasis on the lower performance/budget market, than the high end enthusiasts market. In other words, there is an Intel CPU for every type of PCs, while there doesn’t seem to be the same range from AMD.

All will change again when Intel’s Nehalem processor range is released later in the year, so there’s not much time left for AMD to act, and act they must if they want to stay competitive.

Weekly News Roundup (20 July 2008)

Sunday, July 20th, 2008

E3 just ended in the US, and no surprise then that most of the stories this week are to do with gaming. And just luck would have it, the NPD June figures were released this week, meaning more stories about gaming. The lucky thing for a video website such as this is that gaming and video are now a lot closely related thanks to the PS3’s Blu-ray and to a lesser extent, the Xbox 360’s ill fated support of the HD DVD format. Plus I like video games so that’s my excuse for covering video game content on a website that’s not about video games.

CopyrightBut there are still some non gaming news first, so let’s get through that. Starting with copyright news, Blu-ray might get a new copy protection system dubbed X-Protect Blue. Blu-ray piracy is not a big thing yet, since while ripping the discs are possible, storing it is impractical (considering blank Blu-ray media costs) and uploading and downloading is time and bandwidth consuming (25 GB for a movie? No thanks). Plus, hardly anybody has a Blu-ray player, so the pirated contents aren’t all that popular. Blu-ray really has these “natural” copy protection barriers, so I’m not sure if it needs any more.

Reloaded - Helping tech support everywhere

Reloaded - Helping tech support everywhere

But perhaps it needs a bit of piracy, because there is evidence that the most pirated shows are the ones that win the most awards. I’m not sure I agree with that completely, as wouldn’t a good show automatically mean more piracy anyway, rather than more piracy leading to a good show? I do agree that piracy opens up the shows to a wider array of people, some of which won’t have had access to the show previously (for example, people in other countries). And this kind of “mass-piracy” leads to mass online interest and discussions, which will help the show. So yes, piracy definitely has its advantages … it helped Microsoft to dominate the operating system market, helped game consoles to sell more hardware, so why not TV and movies as well?

And how’s this for an interesting story. Game publisher Ubisoft recently had to turn to a rather strange source to solve a problem. The Ubisoft tech support team posted a NO-CD crack from notorious piracy group Reloaded to solve a DRM related problem. Just goes to show that sometimes DRM does more harm than good, and that piracy can help sometimes too.

High DefinitionIn HD news, at the SinoCES, there was a range of Chinese Blu-ray players on show. We won’t see many of these players being released in the west just yet, I don’t think, as the last thing Sony and co. wants is cheap players stealing their market before they’ve even started to exploit it.

Netflix on the Xbox 360

Netflix on the Xbox 360

While not strictly HD news, but important in that it could become a rival to Blu-ray, is the news that both Microsoft and Sony are investing heavily into movie streaming services for their game consoles. Sony launched their movie download service during E3, and Microsoft teamed up with online video rental giant Netflix to deliver free movies to Xbox Live Gold users (presumably US users only). Microsoft also signed a deal with NBC-Universal to deliver their content through Xbox Live Video Marketplace. I don’t think movie downloads will dominate this generation, but you can see where things are headed even when Sony, Mr. Blu-ray, is backing video downloads for the future.

GamingAnd of course the gaming news mostly lead by stories coming out of the E3. Microsoft started the ball rolling by officially dropping the price of the Xbox 360 20 GB model which is to be discontinued and replaced by a new 60 GB one. Nobody should be surprised at this one if they’ve been following the WNR. What did surprise, and the headlining news of the E3, was the 360 getting Final Fantasy XIII. The previously PS3 exclusive is exclusive no longer, at least in the United States. It makes sense though for publisher Square Enix, because with the 360, they can reach more US users who perhaps were not into the FF series before. Sony weren’t please, obviously, and I can understand why.

Final Fantasy XIII coming to a Xbox 360 near you

Final Fantasy XIII coming to a Xbox 360 near you

I’ve talked to a lot of people about their choice of consoles, and the ones choosing PS3 almost always mentions FF exclusivity as a reason, perhaps *the* reason. This won’t help the Xbox 360 too much, and they do need help if you read our June NPD sales figure analysis, but it won’t hurt either. But wait, there’s more! There was also Lips, the Xbox 360 Karaoke/Dance game with included motion sensing microphone. And a re-design of the Xbox dashboard to make it more Wii-like, complete with customisable Mii-type characters. Overall, Microsoft has had a good E3, probably the best out of the console publishers, but perhaps it’s too little too late.

Nintendo came out with Wii MotionPlus, which adds increased sensitivity and accuracy to the WIi-mote. There will also be a new musical game called Wii Music (how original), which will allow you to control an entire orchestra. Think of it as a more family-friendly version of Guitar Hero.

The PS3, on the other hand, had only as few major announcements. One includes the ending of the 80 GB line, and a price drop as a result. The PS3 lineup will now only feature a single model. Now would be a good time to get the 80 GB, especially if you still need PS2 compatibility. I personally wouldn’t rule out PS2 emulation coming back on a later model, as manufacturing prices drop for the PS3. The message coming out of Sony seems to be “more of the same”, since the PS3’s popularity is growing and all without having to offer any price cuts. Adding more features to add more value, rather than decreasing price to do the same, seems to be Sony’s strategy, in the short to mid term at least.

Fallout 3 banned in Australia

Fallout 3 banned in Australia

And while the hoopla was going on in the US, Australian gamers suffers yet again with Fallout 3 being banned due to simulated drug use. GTA IV, on the other hand, was not banned here and was offered with minor cuts, even though drug use is prominent in the game (but not by the main character, who only shoots cops and innocent people, as well as commit acts of terror with an RPG). Drugs are bad, mmmkay. And to add insult to injury (or in GTA IV terms, to get run over after being shot 78 times by cops), we pay more for censored games than pretty much anybody else in the world. Twice as much, for most game releases. Thank goodness for region-free games and stores like Play-Asia that take care of Australian gamers with discounts and cheap-ish shipping.

Let me check, yep, I think that’s it for this week. Join me next week for a less gaming oriented WNR. I will probably take some time in mid-week to follow up on that CPU story I wrote on the blog last week, as I’ve been running mega CPU poll on the site for a few weeks now with some interesting results. The poll is still open, so make sure you get your vote in. See you next week.

Game Consoles – June 2008 NPD Sales Figure Analysis

Saturday, July 19th, 2008

It’s that time of the month again. The June 2008 NPD sales figures are out, and there are a few interesting happenings this month. E3 has just concluded, and the Xbox 360 was the winner of this year’s event, although it wasn’t one for the books with very few innovations and surprises, not even from Nintendo. But perhaps Microsoft needed that E3, as you will find from this month’s figures the Xbox 360 isn’t doing very well, not compared to the Wii and not the PS3. Could this be the start of a new trend, or is it just a one off due to the strong software line-up Sony had in June (MGS4). Read on to find out. You can read last month’s analysis here. The figures are from NPD, a marketing research firm that releases games console sale data every month.

The figures for US sales in June are below, ranked in order of number of sales:

  • DS: 783,000 (Total: 20.9 million)  
  • Wii: 666,700 (Total: 10.8 million)  
  • PS3: 405,500 (Total: 4.8 million)
  • PSP: 337,400 (Total: 12.1 million)
  • Xbox 360: 219,800 (Total: 10.5 million)
  • PS2: 188,800 (Total: 42.4 million)
  •  

    NPD June 2008 Game Console US Sales Figures

    NPD June 2008 Game Console US Sales Figures

     
    NPD Game Console Total US Sales Figures (as of June 2008)

    NPD Game Console Total US Sales Figures (as of June 2008)

     As you can see from the figures and graphs above, it was a great month for the PS3 (and it was pretty good in software sales too, see below). While the Wii maintained it’s high sales figures way above that of both the PS3 and Xbox 360 combined, PS3 sales exploded nearly doubling last month’s effort. Due to this, it comfortably beat the Xbox 360, again nearly twice as many sales. This should be worrying for Microsoft as 2008 has been a great year for the PS3, and a very average one for the 360. While Microsoft blamed stock shortages early on, there aren’t any excuses for the last few months.

    When put into this context, the recent price drops and the good showing at E3 is now all the more important for the Redmond based company, as it needs to regain the momentum it had last year when it trounced the PS3 for months at a time. The E3 offerings, including snatching the previously PlayStation exclusive Final Fantasy XIII from Sony’s grasps, securing a free movie streaming service for Xbox Live Gold users from Netflix, and re-designing the 360 Dashboard to try and steal some customers from the Wii.

    While Sony can be extremely pleased with recent performances, it needs to be said that June’s performance was largely, if not solely, based on the strong sales for Metal Gear Solid 4, a PS3 exclusive. This is pretty much the first PS3 exclusive title that has reached top spot on the software charts, and if Sony can bring out a few more titles like this, then it can keep the momentum going well into next year. Microsoft had a similar bumper month when Halo 3 was released, but as history tells us, it didn’t last very long. Microsoft, on the other hand, did not have any must-have releases of the same ilk, although Ninja Gaiden II did well.

    Going away from the PS3/360, the “Nintendo Family” consisting of the Wii and DS again did extremely well. The PSP also nearly doubled in sales, and it’s easy to see why Sony is concentrating on promoting the “PlayStation Family”. There is no Xbox family though, as Microsoft does not have a handheld device to compete, although one would say that the DS and PSP does seem to have the handheld market locked down.

    Let’s have a detailed look at the software charts. Sony’s dominance due to MGS4 is clear to see below, snatching 20.4% of the top 10 sales. The Xbox 360 didn’t do that much poorer though, with two titles in the top 10 and 19% of the sales. The Wii again is the winner with 35% and no less than 4 titles in the top 10. Two DS and one PS2 title rounds off the top 10, including Guitar Hero: On Tour for the DS at a high number 2 – it’s even better news for Nintendo because this was not a first party game like most of its other top 10 titles. In fact, the Wii had 2 titles in the top 10 not published by Nintendo, so there’s another criticism of the Wii crossed off the (now very small) list. I know I say this about 10 times every NPD analysis, but again it’s been a good month for Nintendo.

    1. Metal Gear Solid IV (PS3, Konami) – 774,600
    2. Guitar Hero: On Tour (Nintendo DS, Activision) – 422,300
    3. Ninja Gaiden II (Xbox 360, Tecmo/MGS) – 372,700
    4. Wii Fit w/Board (Wii, Nintendo) – 372,700 
    5. Wii Play w/ Remote (Wii, Nintendo) – 359,100
    6. Battlefield: Bad Company (Xbox 360, EA) – 346,800 
    7. Mario Kart w/ Wheel (Wii, Nintendo) – 322,400
    8. Lego Indiana Jones (Wii, Lucasarts) – 294,500
    9. Lego Indiana Jones (DS, Lucasarts) – 267,800
    10. Lego Indiana Jones (PS2, Lucasarts) – 260,300

     So that’s it for the month of June. I loathe to make a prediction next month, but with all things considered, I’m going to go for a very similar situation to this month, except PS3 sales may drop a little due to MGS4 sales dropping off. Wii to dominate, PS3 to come second, and the Xbox 360 to struggle a bit as price cuts only come into effect half way through July. See you next month.

    Weekly News Roundup (13 July 2008)

    Sunday, July 13th, 2008

    Welcome to another issue of the WNR. I finally updated WordPress to the latest version over the week, and the admin interface is looking much better than before. Let’s not waste any time, here’s the news for the week.

    CopyrightStarting with copyright news, the RIAA’s witch-hunt against a home health aide who has never even used a computer was finally dropped, after three years of pursuit. If it takes three years for the RIAA to realise that someone who has never used a computer before can’t possibly be guilty of downloading music, just what other mistakes are they making in their pursuit of copyright violators? Viacom’s contined assault on YouTube/Google has caught the ire of YouTube users, who are posting protest videos on the video sharing site.

    YouTube TargettedA study says that 1 in 3 people break the law by ripping DVDs. I don’t know who commissioned the study, but I suspect it is perhaps a company that would profit from a scare campaign that scares content owners into adding more DRM to their content. I say 1 in 3 people probably don’t even know their computers can play DVDs. A solution to this problem is to put a “copy tax” on blank media and disc writing hardware, to basically fine you for things you might do which may not illegal at all under the fair use provisions. Japan has recently decided against adopting an iPod tax, but that was mainly due to bureaucratic reasons, rather than a reaction to genuine public opposition. I don’t know about you, but I don’t want to be classified a pirate before I even buy a blank disc or an iPod.

    Digital DownloadsBut perhaps the biggest threat to the movie industry is not pirated downloads, but rather, legal downloads, which is cheaper but also makes less profit. That’s certainly what another study says, that digital downloads will dent Hollywood’s bottom line. I think this is inevitable, and the trick would be to get more people to buy downloads, rather than pirate them … you can do that by making prices fairer, and the increased number of buyers should then help make up for any loss in revenue. The traditional disc will still be sold for those who cannot download or still want a physical medium to enjoy their movies on.

    High DefinitionIn HD news, Pioneer demonstrated a massive 16 layer Blu-ray disc that can store 400 GB of data. Not sure I would want 400 GB of my data to be stored on a single easily damaged or lost disc, and given the price of current Blu-ray media, such a disc would cost hundreds of dollars (if it is capable of being mass produced, and not just a lab experiment). External HDD storage is still much cheaper, safer and flexible (not to mention faster in file read/write) – you can get 1 TB drive for a third of the cost of a Blu-ray burner drive, for example.

    Blu-ray Profiles - image curtesy of audioholics.comSony is touting the new interactive elements of Blu-ray (funny how they made fun of the very same elements in HD DVD, and called it a gimmick, during the HD format war). But some of their statements in regards to future Blu-ray interactive features requiring possibly new hardware profiles is a bit disturbing. Many people are now contemplating upgrading their 1.1 players to 2.0, but if a new profile is coming out (and I’m not talking about the audio only profile 3.0), then when does the upgrade stop? I really don’t want to upgrade my HT equipment as frequently as I update my computer, because unlike computers, it’s very hard to find a HT component that’s exactly right for your system – having to do so every 2 or 3 years will be a (very expensive) pain in the butt.

    GamingAnd finally in gaming, Sony’s PlayStation site was hacked earlier in the week. Don’t know how this affects PS3 users, but it never felt right that the PS3 has a web browser but no anti-virus or firewall software (and the PS Store used to be just a website, as opposed to a fully closed system like Xbox Live). The PS3 2.40 firmware debacle was also resolved this week, after a fully working and non corrupting 2.41 version of the firmware was released. The lesson, of course, is to wait before applying new updates and let someone else be the guinea pig. PlayStation Home is still awaiting release, but there is a semi-confirmed date of a northern hemisphere fall/autumn release this year. There is also a rumour of a new PS3 model coming in September, but I don’t know if these last two news items are related or not.

    What is certain is that the PS3 will not be getting a price drop anytime soon, while the Xbox 360 is gearing up for one just around the corner. The PS3 may also get a new motion sensing controller like the Wii, and the Xbox 360 will get one too. If the Xbox 360 can tie in the new Wii like controller with cheap HD motion sensing games downloadable from Xbox Live, then there might be a market there … Wii games are quite expensive, and not in HD, and for a quick spot of arcade action, the Xbox Live cannot be beat – add in a motion sensing controller, then that might be interesting. If not, then playing a Star Wars lightsaber game with such a controller would be ace.

    That’s all the news that caught my eye this week. I’m sure I’ve missed plenty of important news items, but what can you do. See you next week!